DjangoJohnson
Evan Williams 1783 Small Batch Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
October 30, 2021 (edited May 19, 2022)
I tend to write tomes here in my tasting reviews, primarily because this platform serves as a place not only to keep my tasting notes, but to help me retain a whisky diary. You see, I like to remember my experience of a bottle as well as what the whisky tasted like. For example, Maker's Mark is dear to my heart, not only because they make solid bourbon, but because one sunny afternoon back in 2005, with the spring coming on, my buddies Peter and Luke and I killed a bottle of your standard 90-proof Maker's Mark over the course of what I remember being just a wonderful afternoon, sitting on Peter's front porch, conversing on all manner of topics. What did we talk about? Not sure I can remember now. Not sure I could remember the next day, but the memory of being with my friends and drinking whisky and laughing a lot has stuck with me and added to my fondness of Maker's Mark. So, if you'll bear with me, this is part of the explanation of why my "tastings" are so involved.
In any case, this review should (I hope) be shorter. It's been a while since I've laid out money for a budget bourbon. Maybe six months ago, I picked up Evan Williams Bottled in Bond to give it a taste test against Jim Beams Old Tub, and Old Tub was solidly the winner there, but these days I tend to go higher end, so I tend not to dip into the $20-$30 category too often. This Evan Williams 1783 was an impulse buy. I was walking past the Spirits store and popped in, and this was on the shelf for $19.99, and I thought, why not? Again, wondering if there's a budget bourbon out there that could displace Old Tub in my heart. And this gives it a go. If you're familiar with the Evan Williams lineup, this 1783 Small Batch is much better than Black Label and slightly better than Bottled in Bond (otherwise known as White Label); I have a bottle of Single Barrel that I haven't opened yet in my collection, so I don't know if it's better than that, but it's certainly worth the $20 price tag.
The nose is oaky and sweet, but not cloyingly so. I can see why the expert review compares it to an oatmeal raisin cookie, because the sweetness has something of raisins and nutmeg/cinnamon in the aroma, and the flavor profile is undemanding but satisfying if you're expecting this to be what it's marketed as. If you go in expecting more, you'd be disappointed, but if you expected more...well, what can I say? This isn't a whisky that's going to rock your world, but it will satisfy those who like fairly standard and straightforward bourbon flavors without breaking the bank. Because I can get Old Tub for $17 and because I like it a slight bit more, that's still the king of bourbons under $25 for me. But I could see myself buying this 1783 again, especially when the stores run out of stock of Old Tub.
As a side note, while drinking this I started to think, you know how you're always seeing 10 best lists on whisky review sites? One of them you never see is 10 best whiskies to put in a flask when you're headed out to a concert, say, or a show where you know you'll be able to sneak one in. With a flask, of course, nose doesn't particularly matter since you're not going to be sniffing it before it hits your palate. And the nose on this is decent but I'd put this high on a list of flask whiskies, given it's price and strength and the fact it goes down smoothly for what it is. So how about the rest of you out there? Ever use a flask, or is that sort of frowned upon once you start taking whisky seriously? And if you use one, what would be your top flask whiskies?
19.99
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
In answer to flask whiskey that gets the job done Im going OGD 114 which is also imo the best bourbon $25 or less
Love this - love all your backstories! I love how you catalog not just the product but the memory. And yes, some whisky are perfect for the flask!
I own two flasks, one filled with Evan Williams 1783 and the other with Jim Beam Double Oak.
Keep the tomes coming. Yours reminds me of a MM story at the Peach Bowl many years ago. As to the flask issue, it makes me think of football games in my 20s at old Stoll Field. As you walked up the concourse, there was a large sign declaring "no alcohol allowed in stadium". Watch the crowd and notice that all the guys would check to see that their flask was stored away safely.
Knob creek rye store pick was the last flask I carried, close to 2 years ago to our local Catholic fall festival. Fit right in with several other flask carriers. I will say that I’m not Catholic by birth but by marriage and seeing three priests bless a barrel of beer and then tap it was a sight!
@Benji-Robert Correction from my last comment, it's the JD 200 mL that's perfect inside coat pocket sized and shaped like a flask.
@Benji-Robert that's another option, which I used to do post-flask sometimes when I went to the movies. Usually it was a 375 mL JD because it's slender and fits perfectly with an inside jacket pocket (I don't think it's a mistake that they designed their bottle in the shape of a flask). But it does require more forethought than the flask if we're talking holiday situations. You have to anticipate those occasions you might need it ahead of time. I guess I prefer the flask because it's the version of it that's always on call.
just a pocket carry to get you through? something easy and smooth, like gentleman jack or Jameson. if its an insulated flask I'm going cold Jager, or cold hochstadters rock n rye. if the insulated flask is large enough (they exist!), I'm partial to just making my own bottled cocktail. 'sugar cookie' makes a good one
@ctbeck11 I had a flask in my mid-20s that I gave away in my late-20s. Then, a little before covid hit, I went to a family function where alcohol was usually served but one of the in laws had decided to give up drinking and alcohol was no longer being served. And that's a good decision on the part of anyone finding themselves having to make that decision, but it was the type of event where I would have liked a drink and if I'd had a flask I don't think it would have offended anyone if I'd snuck off and had a nip, so I decided to buy one again for those types of situations. But of course, you don't load a great whisky into a flask, and I think your picks are in that perfect range of good tasting but fitting for the flask (although of the four you mention, I haven't yet ventured into Balcones territory). Thanks for sharing!
Good question! It’s been some time since I’ve had a flask, and back then it usually contained JD. If I were to use a flask these days, I could see myself filling it with EC Small Batch, Rittenhouse, or maybe JB Single Barrel if I wanted to up the budget slightly. For something a bit different, I could see Balcones Lineage being a good, sessionable sipper as well.