cascode
Whistlepig 10 Year Small Batch Rye
Rye — (bottled in) Vermont, Canada
Reviewed
February 23, 2022 (edited October 5, 2022)
Nose: Freshly sawn planks, a little white pepper, vanilla, bright aromatic spices (peppermint, anise, clove, cinnamon) and some citrus.
Palate: Slightly dusty, semi-sweet arrival. Pears, pineapple, vanilla but there is minimal development. The texture is curiously thin and there is no depth to the palate.
Finish: Medium but abrupt. It lingers for a moment then suddenly runs out of energy and vanishes into a very mild salted lemon aftertaste.
Nothing to write home about.
This has a simple profile with the usual rye aromas and flavours but it leans a little more than usual towards a citrus personality. The main problem is how thin and shallow this spirit is. There is no mouth-feel at all when it is neat and the palate dissolves quickly into featureless brine.
Surprisingly, water improves it. I thought it would drown easily but a small dash brought out softness, some much-need texture and more rounded aromas, with a little red berry showing up. It does not seem tight when neat, just weak, but it blooms with dilution.
It’s clean, well-made and very easy to drink but this sort of whisky does nothing for me and at the shocking local price of AUD$125 a bottle I would not recommend it.
“Adequate” : 73/100 (2.25 stars)
125.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@cascode Bought separate times, separate places. One as an official 50 ml sample at my favorite store. One was part of a cocktail making kit as a team event during the pandemic. The poor one was in the kit; I did have concerns it was advertised as WP10, but actually something else. Or since it was all sourced, wasn’t sure how much batch variation there is.
@angstrom That's disturbing. Were the samples bought at the same time or was there a fair gap between them? Even if there was that doesn't inspire confidence. I have a sample of the 12 year old waiting for review and I'm expecting it to be better, based on what I've heard.
I had two samples. One awesome, one terrible. Given the high price, I do not like my odds and have avoided purchasing a bottle.