I could not disagree more with the dude that gave this a 2.5 rating (amd then said he was giving it a good score). Dont be fooled by his rating. He almost always gives very low scores to some damn good whiskey. This rye whiskey is so good. Not youthful at all. Great nose followed with a complex taste with notes of maple syup, cocoa, chocolate and hints of light fruits. Incredible mouthfeel and something that makes you want to go back immediately for another taste