3.5 stars - Very good, 750 ml bottle What is the difference between a good whiskey and a great whiskey? This whiskey is very similar to Remus Repeal Batch II, a total oak and cherry bomb. It is very good, clearly old, and unique. But is it legendary? I feel this is a two note wonder, but I need at least three or four major notes to be complex enough to climb into “great” territory. At half the age, I would give the advantage to Bookers for that reason.