DjangoJohnson
Russell's Reserve 6 Year Rye
Rye — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
December 2, 2022 (edited December 5, 2022)
Anyone following me here knows, that in addition to loving a top notch rye, I also love a decent budget rye so I'm always on the lookout. I'm of the opinion that rye tends to be the best value for money style of whisky out there in that you can get really decent stuff without breaking the bank, and even though I have a couple favorites in the under $30 range, my blind spot is the $30-$50 range. If I'm not going for the budget rye, I'm going bigger: cask strength stuff with higher age statements. But there are a few in that $30-$50 range I've been meaning to try that I simply haven't reached: WhistlePig Piggyback comes to mind as well as Michter's and Jack Danie's Single Barrel Rye. But recently, having tasted the Russell's Reserve 10 Year bourbon and seeing this on sale just yesterday after getting out of a meeting where I thought I should treat myself, I figured it's time to hit up the Russell's 6 Year rye, since the community score here for this is exactly the same for the bourbon (currently: 3.75), which puts it in the expect it to be decent but not knock your socks off category, right?
Well, that's exactly what this is, though I'm going to have to go 3.5 myself. It's not going to change your idea of what a rye is, it's not going to rock your world, but unless you're a super snob, you're also not going to pour this down the sink. The nose is nice and full of rye spice with a slight edge of sweetness. At the edge of the spice could either be vanilla or bubble gum here. I've seen other reviewers mention both, and it really could go either way. The complaints about it being 90 proof seem fairly well founded when it hits the tongue, because it's got an ultra-light mouthfeel with the nose spice muted (even though I also can't complain about sipping on a 90 proofer from the perspective of feeling it less tomorrow morning). The finish is of medium-length and the sweetness takes over from the spice on its way out, definitely becoming heavier on the vanilla with a slight hit of mint, but the impression doesn't last terribly long.
It's been about two years since I've had Woodford Reserve Rye, but if I can trust my memory at all, these two bear a striking similarity in profile (as well as price range), but if I had the choice, I think I'd favor the Woodford. Having said that, there are two under $30 ryes that come to mind that I like better than this in both Sazerac and Old Forester (not to mention I gave this whisky's cousin the Wild Turkey 101 rye the same score as this one and that bottle is $15 dollars less), so while I don't think I'm going to have any trouble finishing this bottle (and while I'll likely give some to my dad when he comes over for the football game Sunday to see what he thinks), I doubt I'm going back to this well. If I'm going to drop $36.99 on a Russell's product in the future, it'll be the bourbon, which is amusing in a sense given how much I favor rye. The bourbon is simply the superior product in this line.
36.99
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I wasn’t a huge fan of this one but the single barrel version of this blew me away last time I tried one. I don’t normally care for rye but that one was a notable exception.
@DjangoJohnson here in NJ, Eagle Rare is close to $100. I’ve had a sample once before, and I’d not pay over $40 for it. I need to add Russell’s 10 to my list.
@PBMichiganWolverine Yeah, you should try it. Honestly, with everyone running around losing their minds about Eagle Rare, with Russell's you have a 10 Year age statement that's...well, I think it's profile fits what I like about bourbon more than Eagle does. More oaked and nutty rather than dark berries and jam. Don't get me wrong. I still buy Eagle whenever I see it given it's $30 here (thank god for state run stores keeping it at SRP). But I feel like I should maybe also stock up a little on RR 10 in case the reserves start to dry up.
Sorry—-meant 10yr bourbon by them
@DjangoJohnson the 10yr seems to be an amazing value as well. Never had it, but thought countless times of picking it up