Richard-Davenport
Mortlach 12 Year "The Wee Witchie"
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
September 11, 2023 (edited August 9, 2024)
I'm continuing to work through the bottles in my collection that I've yet to review.
I've started using the Pantone color system, common in paint, because I was growing weary of using similar descriptors for most whiskies; Pantone affords a finer delineation between colors. This one is a clear version of Pantone 153 (a smidgen lighter than the Mortlach 16, which will be reviewed right after this. It's unclear if coloring is added.
Sweet and subtly malty nose: strawberry-rhubarb pie, candied peanuts, and appropriately enough as we ease into Fall, pumpkin bread (I haven't had any since last Fall)--each of these a somewhat different manifestation of the sherry finishing. The palate begins with brown sugar; on the palate, there is a residual bacon note, some very gentle pepper, and a faint tannic bitterness on the long finish, which morphs into a dustiness.
Overall, the impression is sweet, and a tad heavy, but a bit disjointed and lacking a "wow" factor. Nice to drink, but not a must-have. I bought this when I was buying more scotch whisky. It's a nice-to-have whisky if you've got a big enough collection and want a little arcana, but not something to seek out. 3.5 on the Distiller scale.
43.4% ABV.
N.B.: All spirits tasted neat in a Glencairn glass.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@ShatteredArm I'm seeing some of those now with an Internet search--thanks for mentioning.
@Richard-Davenport haven't heard great reviews of the new OBs, but I've had a couple of IB Mortlachs in the 18 year range that are just phenomenal.
@ShatteredArm apparently it is part of some Johnnie Walker blends. Mortlach also did a refresh of the product line a few years back. Perhaps the OBs will improve. My 12 and 16 were purchased 3-4 years ago.
Haven't had an OB Mortlach yet, but I've heard they don't do the distillery justice.