DrRHCMadden
Talisker Dark Storm
Single Malt — Islands, Scotland
Reviewed
February 25, 2024 (edited February 29, 2024)
First there was Storm. Now there is Dark Storm. It has taken me a long time to track down a dram of Dark Storm. Originally released as a TRE I understand this is a very sought after bottling. What I am very unclear on is how it is different to Storm. All I can find is that the Dark Storm uses heavily charred barrels, but that supposed to be what the Storm is; a blend of old and young finished in re-charred barrels. Hmm, perhaps then the Dark Storm is the reference to “the peatiest whisky Talker produces”.
N: Straight in with the good stuff… rich, deep, and evocative. Earthy and slightly mineral undertones deliver a unfolding smoke with a hint of oiliness and a tiny touch of floral intrigue. A peppery and slightly tannic prickle is interesting and mingles with slightly sweet pear and an emergent charred BBQ ends. A storm is indeed brewing…
P: Mouth coating and full with a slight oiliness that holds the palate firmly in place. Smoke is wonderfully enveloping, warm and powerful with red chilli, briny oysters, a hint of iodine or band-aids. This big entry is backed by a fruity berry sweetness, honeyed-malt, preserved lemon peel(?), and gentle tannic spice.
F: Long and changing. The bonfire stays present against a briny sea spray and hits with cracked pepper to chilli heat, some toasty malt, a somewhat astringent tannic-toffee and bright fruity notes. This finish keeps on giving.
It has been suggested to me that Dark Storm is a good equivalent to the 2021 8 y/o sea fury special edition. So, I opted to pull up my notes and pour a measure of the Sea Fury alongside the Dark Storm. I can agree that there is cross-over, particularly on the nose but this Dark Storm is quite different. Here the combination of heavy char imparts a toasty depth that comes across as honeyed malt and a thicker smokiness but it doesn’t broil with the same depths and power of the Sea Fury and lacks the more obvious vanillin. the Sea Fury sports a hefty almost 60% ABV, the Dark Storm comes in at the Talisker standard of 45.8% so the comparison isn’t fair from the get go. But, this Dark Storm delivers well. The lift of the sweet fruity notes, and the delicacy of the smoke in spite of its big presence is very well done. The Storm was unnecessary, it was the calm before the true (Dark) Storm.
Now if you’ll excuse me, I have a Sea Fury to attend to under the Dark Storms waves…
Price is for 1000 ml bottle.
Distiller whisky taste #258
[Pictured here with a clutch of sapphirine schists from southern Madagascar. Thats sapphirine, not sapphire. Sapphirine is much better. 560-530 million years ago Madagascar for caught up in the assembly of the Gondwanan supercontinent and the closure of the Mozambique ocean. Essentially Madagascar got smashed between India to the east and East Africa to the west. During this time some 720 million year old oceanic sediments were metamorphosed at ultra high temperatures of 800-1000 degrees C at depths of 25-35 km; the result these spectacular rocks.]
Talisker running scores:
T10: 4/5
T18: 4.75/5
T8 2021 Special Release: 4.5/5
Skye: 3.25/5
Port Ruighe: 2.75/3
Storm: 3.5/5
Dark Storm: 4.25/5
57 North: 4.25/5
X Parley Wilder Seas: 4.25/5
140.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Scott_E Yes I think it may be a UK/European TRE only now. @DrRHCMadden I grabbed one from Vintage Direct about a year ago when they had some grey-market stock, but that’s the last local bottle I’ve seen.
@cascode oh well there you go! All the online distributors for dark storm are out of stock, have been a long while. Thats why I thought it had perhaps been discontinued. For 1L AUD$140 is a steal. I got a bottle of Surge at Perth airport in July, will open it in the next day or two.
@DrRHCMadden I believe Dark Storm is still a standard TRE expression (it has been around for a decade). Surge is/was also a TRE expression but was only issued in 700ml size, and I think it has already been discontinued. I have a bottle that I have not opened yet but I've read many conflicting reviews about it.
I picked up a bottle on an European travel. 1L for about €90 (give or take a euro). Hopefully I will get to it sooner than later.
@cascode they have a very different purpose the 8 and the DS. And that much is clear, they have purpose (where Skye and Storm do not). It seems as though dark Storm is no longer available? Has it been replaced by Surge (which I have up next).
@DrRHCMadden Great tasting notes. I’m very fond of this, and luckily I still have the last of three bottles I bought a few years ago still in the stash. I does seem to be divisive, however. Many love it, a few absolutely hate it and for the most part the critics who generally know what they are talking about seem to not like it greatly. No idea why but it’s a 4 star dram for me at least 👍 I like that 2021 8 year old special edition too, but I would never have considered the two whiskies to be at all similar.