cascode
Glenfiddich 21 Year Reserva Rum Cask Finish
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
May 5, 2024 (edited August 13, 2024)
Nose; Raisins, malted honey, marzipan, a curious smidge of smokiness no doubt coming from the rum casks. Water makes the nose a little more fragrant.
Palate: Sweet and soft arrival, very easy and approachable. Demerara sugar opening onto toffee and chocolate covered raisins. A light spice note of ginger and clove, and a mild coffee presence but it is all very soft. The texture is light but there is an oily quality. Water turns the texture creamy, which is pleasant, and it also opens the palate by bringing out more sugars but I did not detect much rum character. If adding water don’t add more than a half teaspoon to a dram as this is only 40% abv.
Finish: Short. Sweet malt fading to cereal.
The rum cask influence on this extremely approachable malt is subtle. The distillate speaks clearly of its Glenfiddich origin and the wood has not been allowed to overtake the proceedings. There is no tannin whatsoever.
Glenfiddich does not garner love from hard-core enthusiasts, which is a pity. It may lack the intense character and complexity of some whiskies but I can honestly say that I’ve never had a Glenfiddich that I’ve actively disliked. They can be very good but for me they don’t ever rise to a sublime level.
However the two biggest things against this dram are the cost and the measly alcohol level. AUD$275 is the best local price I’ve seen and for that money there are other bottles I’d rather buy, and crippling a nice whisky like this by bottling it at only 40% is criminal. If it was 46% (preferably) or even 43% it would be substantially more impressive and much better value.
Tasted at the Glenfiddich Whisky Lounge, from a 2024 batch bottle.
“Good” : 83/100 (3.5 stars)
275.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@cascode thanks for the recommendations. I love the Bunna 18! Sounds like the HP 15 and Dalmore CM will need to go higher on my wishlist.
@jdriip Thanks :) Highland Park 15 (the one in the cream-coloured ceramic bottle) is less expensive and I think better, but of a similar profile and the same goes for anCnoc 18. Bunnahabhain 18 is more “old school sherried” in style, as is Glenfarclas 21, but both are around the same price. For a sweeter profile Dalmore Cigar Malt pretty nice. In a peated style Lagavulin 12 from 2020, 2021 or 2022 would be a good choice and Ledaig 18 is always a favourite for me. That’s just off the top of my head but I’d buy any of those in preference, and they would all be more complex, interesting and cheaper. Cheers!
@cascode thanks for the review. Always enjoy your insights. You mention other bottles you would rather buy than this one. Would you mind listing a couple?