Nose: cedar and graham cracker, some herbal tones, oily, slightly nutty Palette: visocity costs the tongue with sweet cotton candy, cola starts to come in, warm vanilla, mid palette has that baking spice graham cracker flavor, some rye spice on the back, vanilla, more of that cola, long finish that changes flavor, sweet to savory. Very good. Cola lingers long Compared to 9 year: this bottle has been opened for a year Nose: citrus, vanilla, caramel Palette: not as viscous or sweet as the 10, chicory with slight cola, slight marshmellow and citrus on the back end, might be the rye spice. Finish medium length