A few surprises in this bottle. 1) The beautifully thick and hefty aluminum seal covers a plastic screw-on cap. 2) Opening that plastic cap reveals an aroma much closer to Pinot Grigio than anything from the Scottish part of the globe. After it settles a bit, the nose is light and sweet, losing the acidic aroma of dry white whine, yet retaining the apples, pears and melons. The palate is more of the same, with Fuji apples leading the way (somewhat fitting, no?) and richly supported by a mess of other fruits that commingle so well as to be nearly indiscernible individually. Dig a little and you get lemon rind, sweetened limes, a hint of juniper and coriander, and then rose petals. The finish is brief and clean, leaving just the faintest floral hint as a precursor for the next sip. This interests me greatly. I love Scotch, I'm intrigued by Irish Whiskey, and I enjoy American Whisky. This takes notes from all three, and creates something all its own. Unique, and yet easily associable with a well-liked known. I get no peat or smoke, and while I'm normally a peat-head, I don't miss it here. The balance is amazing, the depth and variety of flavors astounding, and the clean finish make this an easily quaffed summer drink. But really...a plastic cap on a $90 bottle of whisky? :-/
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I say F the cork. Screw cap just seems safer and more practical to me. As long as the juice tastes good, and it's protected with a tight seal, that's all that matters. Great review though!
You are certainly right! Appearance of a bottle is important and cork simply looks better! Yet, Japanese aim for perfection... so we have to accept life's little disappointments ;-)
I know, I know...good screw-on lids preserve better than anything else. I'm just a little nostalgic, and there's something about the quality of a good wooden cap and stout, sturdy cork to differentiate between "the good stuff" and the cheap rotgut on the bottom shelf. I know the stereotype isn't true: This bottle and my Nikka malts prove good stuff can be had beneath a twist-off cap, while the cork in my CR Cornerstone blend is loose and doesn't seal worth a damn. But...nostalgia...or something... :-)
The screwtop is there intentionally - the bottle costs certainly enough to justify a quality cork; BUT Japanese are very much concerned that a cork *could* spoil the whisky! And, as you might have noticed, the screwtop is of high quality, including a seal.