Erogers100
Lagavulin 16 Year
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
March 6, 2017 (edited January 12, 2018)
It has been stated that many eloquent reviewers have posted notes about this classic whisky, so I’m not sure I can add much to the Lag 16 anthology. Nevertheless, here are my thoughts.
Visual: In the nosing glass it is a deep amber color. A swirl creates several substantial legs that slowly slide back into the dram.
Nose: Dark and brooding with muted smoke, some magic marker, orchard fruits, and salt water. Nosing again after several minutes and a couple of sips, I pick up a hint of dark brown sugar.
Palate: Honey sweetness greets the tip of the tongue, with dried fruits showing up mid-palate, along with campfire smoke. There is a meaty quality to the overall flavor, reminiscent of smoked ham and barbecued beef. The mouthfeel is full and rich. Elegant peat and seaweed follow the dram down as you swallow. The savory qualities are accompanied by a continued dried fruit sweetness at the end.
Finish: The finish is long and warming, with the peat leaving a satisfying, smoky sensation. Breathing out through the nose reveals just a hint of that medicinal, camphor quality that peat sometimes brings to the party.
This is a category defining whisky –representing the best (IMHO) of the Islay whiskies I’ve tried so far. The prices seem to be rising precipitously, but perhaps this is deserved given the respect and admiration this dram garners. I’ve read fairly recently posted reviews that indicated prices in the $55 to $60 US range, whereas I purchased this bottle in February 2017 for $99 in the Tampa area. Pricing is now approaching splurge territory. I suspect if it continues this trajectory, it will migrate to luxury and ultimately to conspicuous consumption!
I think this is worth 94/100 for 5 Stars.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@RuddyM - A stock-up price to be sure!
Just got it for $75 at Costco. A steal!
It collects dust on the shelves here in Virginia at $109 a bottle. That makes it an easy decision for me to pony up another Andrew Jackson and opt for the 12 year cask strength.
$70 would be a steal. Minimum shelf price in MI is $103. We have some of the highest prices and it sucks. Nice review though. Great whisky
@Soba45, yes, me too. Some have even called it monumental.
Great to see you finally got to taste this classic :-)
@revkev12 thanks for the tip!
It's consistently been priced around $70 near me in Chicago (at least at Binny's...I can't vouch for other liquor stores). I'll have to check the pricing next time I'm there and see if that holds true. One bargain hunting pro-tip: if you enjoy any of the Diageo Distiller's Editions (Laga, Talisker, Oban, etc.), keep an eye out for clearance sales in November every year. It's not uncommon, at least near me, to find bottles for nearly half off so they can make room for the new batch of DE bottlings.
$90 in NJ, Total Wines. Just last year, I bought it for under $70
geografically = geographically
@Rick M. That's a big delta. I'm going to have to comparison shop for this one when I get the itch.
I refused to buy recently at Total Wines in Naples, FL because the price was $99. Total Wines in the Boston area has a price of $69. Same chain, $30 difference in price geografically. Go figure!