This is the second time Springbank leaves me on the fence with one of its expressions (the other being the 9 Gaja Barolo). A part of me gives it a 4, and another really perplexed part of me gives it a 3. The burgundy casks have really muted the typical Springbank flavor profile (and if you love this Campbeltown distillery that's a letdown). As for the predominant winy element... if you love wine finishes, you'll love this. If you don't... good luck.