Dreaming-of-Islay
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
June 20, 2017 (edited November 18, 2017)
Batch B517 (62.1%, May 2017 release) - I was very excited to try this when I found it in Miami after searching through 5 or 6 different liquor stores. This may be my platonic image of bourbon. Neat, the nose definitely hits you with the heat, but not in an unpleasant acetone way at all (the benefit of the 12 years that this barrel proof bourbon has aged). With a little water, which I prefer, there is a complex bouquet -- a word I hate, but which is perfectly appropriate here, as I get beeswax, spring meadow flowers, an oily or buttery scent, as well as the usual sweet caramel flavors and some sharper edges from the oak. The palate is so lively and transforms constantly as I roll each sip around my tongue and the sides of my mouth, with a thick, buttery mouthfeel and a lot of oak and toasted wood. The finish lasts forever and warms the entire mouth, all the way through the throat, with a nice honeyed touch. It has no burn, only a constant, growing warmth and tingle that just never leaves the mouth. Lots of wood and spice, especially cinnamon, throughout. Remarkable, amazing. Aberlour A'bunadh and Ardbeg Uigeadail were some of my first experiences with cask strength/near cask strength whiskies, and I'd rate this one several cuts above A'bunadh (of which I'm not the biggest fan). Bravo, Elijah Craig (it almost makes me forgive you for taking away the 12-year small batch, which was delicious and so much more obtainable).
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I also just acquired a B517 Batch bottle *124.2 proof bottle, feeling fortunate as I prefer the lower proofs to the higher, in this range.
Very nice review!!
Strange I just a side by side with a few friends I brought the b517 I bought Friday unopened and he had brought batch a117 to do side by side. It might be because I haven't let as much air into it . But personally I thought the a117 was a smidgen better but was equally disappointed that both didn't as much of a mouthful presence. As some of the older pre bottle change batch BP's. I liked the B517 enough to if I see it I'll snag one but it felt all around thin. I'm hoping some air will help
Nice review!
Paul, it's definitely a strange one supply-wise. The local liquor store where I found it had multiple bottles, whereas I hear of people in other areas where it's allocated or done by lottery. It was $70, so not cheap, but also not as marked up as some places I see online. And the store had Ardbeg Dark Cove Committee Release to boot (2 bottles!)! It was an expensive trip today.
Great review
This one has been on my list for a while. If I ever spot a bottle I will grab it for sure