Dreaming-of-Islay
Longrow Peated
Single Malt — Campbeltown, Scotland
Reviewed
July 24, 2017 (edited August 5, 2017)
Thank you to Davie Warner for this sample (and double thanks for pointing out to me I initially posted it to the wrong bottle page)! Longrow's most intriguing feature is a unique flavor of peat on the nose, like a well-oiled leather. It's unlike any other scotch I've ever had. As the smoke clears, the scotch falls squarely within the Ardbeg-Kilchoman Machir Bay spectrum of citrus-flavored peated scotches. This is a dead ringer for Machir Bay to me, where a bit of sherry finishing mellows out the peat. The finish is not quite like either of those two Islay scotches, but it's quite ashy and grassy, like throwing fresh hay on a fire pit. Trying more and more of these quality no age statement scotches makes me appreciate how important it is to try a scotch and judge it on its own merits.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Great comparison! I found the machir Bay to be much more of a sweet, fruit salad vs the long row which simply smacks more of a punch in terms of a finish. Springbank whisky just
Excellent notes! Glad you enjoyed it!
So, are you saying, don't judge a scotch by it's label? 😀