cascode
Edradour 10 Year The Distillery Edition
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
January 27, 2018 (edited November 15, 2018)
Nose: Cider vinegar and malty spiced notes - an aroma remarkably like still active malt wort. Spicy oak aromas, sherry, some caramel and vanilla. An earthy and slightly dank note underpins everything. It's not unpleasant, but unusual, and keeps developing for a good while. A dash of water disperses the earth dankness and highlights the sherry.
Palate: A sweet and dense malty/fruity arrival that develops some gingery spice. The texture is on the thick and chewy side. Fruit and nut milk chocolate. Water highlights the heavy fruit character and tones down the spice, which thickens the texture even more.
Finish: Medium/long. Oloroso sherry with spices on the end that tend to turn a little sour in the aftertaste.
A curious whisky. The nose has an interesting winey/earthy quality that makes you expect something bold and interesting of a similar character on the palate. However when you get to the palate it suddenly veers off course into grassy, vegetal flavours, before eventually recovering and getting back onto the original track for the finale. It was interesting and instructive to try, but I'm not going to buy a bottle, and to be honest it's a bit rough.
Tasted from a 30ml sampler.
"Adequate" : 72/100 (2 stars)
80.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Yes, I tasted the Caledonia just a couple of days ago (bought a bottle after a whisky tasting event) and it was certainly a more rounded and complete experience, but it also has that funny disconnect in the palate so I guess that's part of the distillery character.
I find that Edradour’s finished versions are much better, seems to knock out that bitter end. Like Caledonia for example