PBMichiganWolverine
Cutty Sark Prohibition Edition
Blended — Scotland
Reviewed
March 18, 2018 (edited October 21, 2024)
Back as a young kid sitting in rear seat of my dad’s gas guzzling Chevy Nova, I remember seeing these Cutty Sark billboards all through the Jersey Turnpiike. I always wondered what’s this bottle called “cutie shark”? I even then named my toy pirate ship The Cutie Shark. In retrospect, no decent pirate worth his salt and respect would name a ship like that, but anyway...that was the world of a 5 year old. Then much later in life, age 14, I bought my first bottle of liquor. Not to drink...but to use in my science experiment, to show how alcohol can be used instead of gas engines for cars. That bottle was a Cutty Sark. ( technically, my dad bought it). Much much much later in life, now that I have 450+ bottles of whisk(e)y, I always treated Cutty Sark like a snob. Telling myself that “why would I want a pour of this bottom shelf piss and take a hit to my liver, when I can have a single malt?’ Yeah...a snob. But I did have a pour of this recently. And I so,stand corrected. It’s actually freakin good. Granted, it’s no blend at the level of Glaser’s creations, but it’s damn good nonetheless. Cherries and red fruit complement a nice backbone of heather and honey. A tiny bit of smoke, just a whiff. I gotta say, some of these blends that I considered bottom shelf “piss” are coming out with variants that are really affordable (sub $40) and just well made...the Jack Daniels Single Barrel Barrel Strength comes to mind first and foremost. Well done my merry band of “cutie shark “ pirates ...
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Richard-ModernDrinking that explains it. I’m favorably impressed by this one (and that Tullamore 14 we had) to actually buy them both
I was well impressed with this. The Edgrington rep who poured it implied it was a blend of their malts -- Macallan, Highland Park and Glenrothes -- plus North British grain. Yet it was better than any of the entry level bottles from those distilleries. That makes sense, actually, as young whisky rarely shines when sold as a single malt. A blend will introduce the complexity that you otherwise usually only get from an older malt.
@Soba45 a tour of the Betty Ford clinic 😊. I didn’t realize I was at 399...now I think I’ll have to line up something special
Do you have anything special lined up for review 400? :-)
@cascode. Yeah—give this a try, along with the Jack Daniels Single Barrel Barrel Strength. Well worth it and punches above its price point
Arrrr, me little cutie shark. There's certainly a big difference between what I like to call "affordable blends" (many of which are sadly maligned) and true bottom-shelf supermarket no-name swill. 4 stars, however, that's certainly a vote of confidence! Must try this now.
@Rick_M yeah, and if it takes off, maybe I can give up my day job and pursue writing commercial jingles. Or maybe not...
“Cutie Shark” does have a nice ring to it. Are you trying to feel us out for a new nickname? :)