Mac 12 is a lot better. Mac 10 oak is better too. I didn’t like the mash up... it’s almost like the Oak and Sherry finish are competing too much. Might be good if you have never tried the stand alone 12 or 10 but I found this pretty disappointing considering the price. All that said I finished the bottle so it’s not terrible... just not as good as I had heard and hoped. I wouldn’t purchase another bottle.