LeeEvolved
Scapa Skiren
Single Malt — Islands, Scotland
Reviewed
August 6, 2018 (edited November 27, 2018)
This sample is from the other distillery on the island of Orkney: Scapa. These guys are less than a half mile from the superstars named Highland Park, but their whisky is miles apart. Scapa uses water for their malts that is piped in and doesn’t flow through the natural peat beds covering the island. Therefore, they aren’t a peated whisky. Scapa’s offerings are closer to Speyside and Lowland style malts and are more honeyed.
This distillery was founded in 1885 and is currently owned by Pernod Ricard. They make around a million liters per year and currently only offer a 14, 16 and 25 year old, official distillery bottle. The rest is NAS, like the Skiren, or shipped off for use in blends.
This NAS Skiren is 40% ABV and is light gold with oily and watery legs running down the taster. I’m pretty sure it is chill filtered and has added color, but I don’t have the bottle in front of me, as this sample was provided by my friend @Scott_E, from Long Island, NY.
The nose is a wonderful fruit basket of flavors: apples, pears and melons along with some nice vanilla sweetness. There are ripe berries in here as well. I do get a nice backbone of ex-bourbon wood, too. It has an excellent nose, for sure.
The palate has similar fruit notes from the nosing, but there’s serious mouthfeel issues here: it’s harsh and dry and doesn’t coat anything. My opinion is that it’s just too light. It needs a bit more well-aged juice in the mix along with a hearty bump in ABV. But then again, they probably aren’t going for that here so it’s just wishful thinking on my part.
The finish is medium with a dry and salty, island-style feel. The fruits still linger a bit, but the dryness is just too powerful to make it very satisfying.
Overall, this is a serviceable dram but the fact the age statement bottles are so much more expensive than not only their Orkney counterparts, but most Speyside and Highland distilleries, it’s hard to justify spending the big bucks to find out if they’re worth it. I like the fruity aspects, but I can find those elsewhere for a much better price. Why gamble?
That said, this is a 2.75-3 star dram tops. It’s cool to be able to try this distillery, but I doubt I’ll be back for something else unless a great deal happens to fall into my lap. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Rick_M @Scott_E - looking back through my personal spreadsheet I see that I had the Scapa 16 a few years ago and gave it 3 stars, so I’d say I don’t need to go any deeper with this distillery.
@LeeEvolved Scapa had a good thing going with the 16 year old, which is unfortunately discontinued. I agree that this is overpriced for what you get. I did read the bottle and there is no indication about NCF or color so you could probably safely assume all the above has happened. Only real statement is 100% first fill American Oak casks and some tasting notes.
@LeeEvolved - your opening paragraph says it all.