Nose: 4 | a bit muted, but from a freshly cracked bottle; need to revisit Palate: 4.25 | rich, dense, powerful; some sweetness upfront followed by mint and spice on the tail end Finish: 4 | decently long spice on the finish Price: 4 | definitely worth the $60 Verdict: Bottle A very flavorful, limited-release, barrel proof 9 year rye for $60? Yes please.