LeeEvolved
Nikka Whisky From the Barrel
Blended — Japan
Reviewed
September 9, 2018 (edited September 11, 2018)
I recently did a 3-way, Japanese whiskey tasting flight using samples generously supplied by my NJ connection: @PBMichiganWolverine. This blend from Nikka finished in third place behind the Ohishi Single Sherry Cask and the vaunted Hibiki 21.
This was bottled at 51.4% and appeared copper gold in the tasting glass, with tiny and oily beads around the edge. It took a minute or two before a few, sparse legs ran back down the sides. Thickness.
The nose was initially grainy with a wonderful cedar note. Light and lively rye spices appeared after some time (odd, to me) along with faint smoke. The palate was grain heavy at first, with some spice and smoke before turning malty with sherry and floral flavors. The mouthfeel was solid, albeit a tad harsh. The finish is medium-long and spicy. It’s smooth but turns dry at the very end.
Overall, it’s a 4 star dram for sure- it just doesn’t hold up next to the well-aged Hibiki or the surprising upstart Ohishi. Thanks again, Mr B. They were 3 great samples. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@LeeEvolved, this whisky keeps getting consistently good grades. A good cask strength for the money.
@LeeEvolved when I first had the Hibiki 21, I actually thought it was “okay”. I had to wait for some time for that liquid to sit in the opened bottle before I loved it, and likewise fell into my top 5 or 6
@cascode @PBMichiganWolverine - yeah, I kinda expected that going in. It wasn’t meant to be a contest between the 3 whiskies, but more of a progression of flavor. I actually started with the Ohishi, thinking it would be the weakest, but ended up preferring it to the Nikka. They were all quite good, but the Hibiki 21 took a place in my overall Top 5. I WASN’T expecting that.
@LeeEvolved A great whisky but it's punching a bit over it's weight class against the Hibiki 21, nonethelees I'd call it better VFM.
@LeeEvolved my gut tells me very few whiskies will keep pace with that 21. Glad you liked it