cascode
Tobermory 10 Year
Single Malt — Islands, Scotland
Reviewed
September 20, 2018 (edited July 25, 2022)
Nose: Gristy, grassy and fresh with citrus overtones. A very cereal-driven nose with a bracing medicinal herbal touch. There's also an oily maritime quality to it that I find very attractive and a hint of smoke, but so fleeting as to be just a flight of fancy.
Palate: A sweet and tingly spice arrival. It's lightly creamy in character but also crisp and clean. The development is slow and measured, gradually building up flavours of sweet-and-sour citrus, brine, licorice, barley sugar, ginger and peat (not smoke, peat). It has a pleasant texture that is slightly oily but dry. As it rests in the glass it becomes more and more salty.
Finish: Medium/long with minty, maritime cereal flavours that have an almost anaesthetic quality that must come from an interaction with wood tannin. This fades to a refined sweetness that lasts and lasts.
This is a most interesting and elegant malt with great finesse. I've been meaning to get around to tasting it for some time and I'm not disappointed. It's a subtle one that conveys many impressions.
It's maritime, but not the sledgehammer bonfire on the beach sort, nor the blanketing sooty fog rolling in from the Atlantic. It's much more a quiet stroll by yourself on a deserted shingle beach on a cold, cloudy day - oyster shells crunching underfoot, chill surf hissing on the stones and curlews crying in the distance. A most evocative frisson of a whisky - lovely, austere, complex and gentle, like a Hitchcock blonde.
"Very Good" : 85/100 (4 stars)
100.0
AUD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Ctrexman The 12 year old replaced the 10 a couple of years ago, not long after I did this review. I tried it at the time and thought it was quite different to the old 10, but I didn't review it. I picked up a 30 ml sample not long ago so I must do a review soon.
This is 12 yr now but your notes here convey nicely. Plenty of malt and salt
Talisker 10 seems to be the "winner" so far... :-)
@1901 Nice. We’re on the exact same page :)
Great lists @cascode & @Generously_Paul - almost a dozen different offerings mentioned. Hopefully @LeeEvolved and @PBMichiganWolverine chime in too
Laphroaig, Ardbeg, Talisker, Tamdhu, Ledaig. All wonderful 10 year olds.
@SolanaRoots my vote to Spingbank and Talisker
@cascode @SolanaRoots Good calls as well! I really like Ben Nevis 10 and Springbank 10.
In no particular order the 10s that first come to mind are Springbank, Hazelburn, Talisker, Benromach, Ardbeg, Port Charlotte, Laphroaig, Ben Nevis and now Tobermory.
@AntonioSchmid -Nice, good calls. Springbank, Benromach, Talisker for me then it becomes murky to round out a top 5 (plenty to choose from). Now based on the @cascode review, I need to pay attention to Tobermory
@SolanaRoots Talisker 10 and Ardbeg 10 for me! :-)
Nice review @cascode - would be curious to hear the consensus top 10 year old scotch offerings.
@1901 Ha ha! Nice :-)
Ditto what @Richard-ModernDrinking said. Beautiful imagery. Tobermory is North by Northwest too :-)
You sold me on this even before you brought Eva Marie Saint into the picture!