I'd give this a 4.0+ for taste, knocked back for the crazy MSRP. I gave this very high marks when I tried it at the SF Whiskey Fest in 2017. I've had it a couple of times since then, and it stands up well when it's the only CS rye of a lineup... but when you start comparing it head to head with other rich ryes, it loses some steam. I did this side-by-side with the Booker's Rye, and it was clear the Booker's is head and shoulders above the Black Price. (Freudian slip on the typo, but decided to leave it.)