Whiskey_Hound
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
February 21, 2019 (edited September 29, 2019)
Batch C917. 65.5%.
I'd heard the hype for quite some time, so I decided to finally take the plunge and shell out for this one. This will be the first of a short string of bourbon reviews, and I've got to say this one is my favorite by a decent amount (also by far the most expensive).
I often read comments where reviewers suggest that a particular whiskey is almost there, and that a cask strength release would put it over the top. Heaven Hill ensures that one will never say such a thing about Elijah Craig, with this Barrel Proof taking what is a pretty decent entry level bourbon and bringing it to its full potential.
Nose: The nose makes itself known immediately. Caramel, vanilla, crisp red apple, cinnamon, black pepper, and a heavy oak presence. Clove and nutmeg. Black cherry. Almond and walnut. Also a big leather note, like a baseball glove. Enough complexity to mask most of the ethanol. Very nice start.
Palate: The oak is presence is even more prominent than it was on the nose. Nice barrel char. Caramel, vanilla, and cola are the most prominent. Nutmeg, brown sugar, and cocoa are also there. It's mostly sweet, but there is some black pepper and cinnamon spice. Done to perfection, and astoundingly drinkable without water at 131 proof.
Finish: Long finish that comes in waves. Not all that hot. I'll call it a warming finish. Definitely cinnamon and black pepper, but there are sweeter chocolate and cola. Amazing from start to finish.
This is my first batch of ECBP, and now I'm going to be hunting down as many as I can possibly find. It's an absolutely phenomenal experience. At $90, it's an expensive buy, but worth every penny. I think that the standard EC is a respectable entry level bourbon. But at Barrel Proof, this stuff really shines. Well done on top shelf pour, Heaven Hill.
90.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Whiskey_Hound yeah—EC BP is still available in NJ, I just picked one up from Wine Anthology in Summit. where in NJ are you?
@PBMichiganWolverine Great points. I've yet to try any of the BTAC or the Blanton's SFTB. Price point (and the fact that I can't actually buy the latter) has kept me away from them. Same with the Four Roses LESB. Fortunately, ECBP B517 is still available all over Jersey, so of course I'll be taking your advice and grabbing one. It's nice to get some bourbon recommendations from a formidable Scotch buff such as yourself
@Rabbit_in_Red I think the best bourbon I’ve had was the FOur Roses 2016 LESB, but at $250, it’s pricey. For under $100, can’t beat EC Barrel proof. For $150, can’t beat Blanton’s SFTB ( only available in EU though).
@BDanner, @PBMichiganWolverine it's a toss up between this one and the B517(This is the one I sent in a sample @PBMichiganWolverine) as to which is better but both are excellent and a notch above the C918 I have open right now. The whole 2017 batches we're just stellar!
@PBMichiganWolverine 100% agree. The two best bourbons you can buy outside of BTAC (which ain’t worth the price imo).
@BDanner can’t gp wrong with any of the batches...they all might be jusr a few standard deviations from each other
The only batch I've had is B517. It is delicious, but I have no other batch to compare it to.
On a related note—-I think the B517 batch was the one that got stellar accolades.
@Whiskey_Hound this and blanton’s SFTB are my favorites—simply can’t beat the bang for buck. Four roses LESB is great, but expensive. And the BTACs are silly expensive