When I got my latest batch of samples from @PBMichiganWolverine and saw this rye mixed in I was expecting the worst. I’m not a rye fan to begin with and with a name like Whip Saw I had the feeling it was going to be rough, hot and fit for cleaning out my drains. Let’s see what’s really going on here, shall we? This is a blend of different undisclosed whiskies aged up to 7 years, then finished in wine barrels that held Pinot Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon (I’m a sucker for a good wine finish so maybe this won’t be that bad after all). Bottled at 45% ABV and I have no info on chill filtration or colorant, but the color is a beautiful burnt orange like autumn leaves. The mash bill is 76% rye, 21% corn and 3% malted barley.
The nose is all wine. Dry Cabernet and very fruity...intriguing. Minty rye, red grapes, low sugar grape jelly and prunes. Almonds, cherries and marzipan. Sweet and tart raspberries and blackberries. A bit of a medicinal/doctors office note, and believe it or not, children’s Amoxicillin (you know, the pink antibiotic that tastes like gum). Caramel, toffee, vanilla, incredibly rich and savory after it sits a while.
Water tones down the wine notes a bit and brings out more of the rye spice and some apples. Very creamy after sitting with water.
The palate begins with distinct wine notes up front with rye spice right behind it. Light mint, tart berries and apples. Sweet grapes, cherries, marzipan and almonds. Caramel apples, vanilla, wine soaked oak, more rye, cloves and nutmeg.
Water has the same effect as with the nose.
A light to medium bodied mouthfeel that is dry and mouthwatering at the same time.
The finish is long, very long. So long I was still tasting it hours later. Red wine, sweet and tart raspberries, dry.
To say that I was pleasantly surprised is a gross understatement. This is good, great even. Best rye I’ve ever had (again I’m a sucker for a good wine finish). Wonderfully pronounced wine notes, smooth with almost no alcohol feel to it. Not much here to not like except maybe the finish could have been a bit sweeter and it could have used more depth overall. All in all this is a fantastic rye. For only $50 it’s a great value as well. 4.25 and highly recommended if you are a red wine drinker.
Cheers
50.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Generously_Paul yeah, it’s one of the few on my repurchase list. I don’t often do that, but this was pretty good at a nice price
@PBMichiganWolverine liked it so much I bought a bottle and already drank 1/4 of it.
@PBMichiganWolverine I agree, I might just have to grab one of these and bring it out whenever I have wine drinkers over
This might be a repeat buy for me. With the exception of the staples ( Lag16, Ardbeg Corey/Uigi/10), Talisker 10, I don’t do repeat buys. But at $50, this is worthwhile having around
@The_Rev I absolutely hated the Slaughter House too. This one is far more balanced, no artificial sweetness and a much better pour. The Straight Edge isn't half bad either but this one is the pick of the bunch IMO
I'll have to check this one out. I was a bit put off by the Slaughterhouse American Whiskey from the same line, but rye+red wine barrel tends to work well for my palate.
I was pleasantly surprised by this as well. They balanced the rye and wine quite deftly. Glad you liked it