I haven't had Johnnie Walker Black in ages, so I bought a 50 mL for a ridiculous $3.50. But, this is good sipping Scotch. There's a nice hint of ash and peat, mostly on the nose and the finish. I always avoided this and Johnnie Walker in general because of the price and proof of their offerings, but I'd consider buying a 375 mL for future comparison to Double Black or Green. I don't think it is worth the price for a full bottle since there are a lot of great whiskeys around $40, but combined with another 375 mL purchase that's a good evening of tasting. I think at 86 proof this would be a home run, but big-brand Scotch always has to milk their dollars. For reference, in NC the 375 mL is $20.95 and 750 mL is $41.95.