LeeEvolved
Tamdhu Ambar
Single Malt — Speyside, Scotland
Reviewed
April 20, 2019 (edited August 18, 2022)
Ah, Tamdhu. If Macallan is the Sak’s Fifth Avenue of sherried malts and Tomatin is the Walmart, then you’d be the JC Penney. What we have here is a new, travel retail exclusive called Ambar (which is Spanish for amber. Spanish because they used refilled, Spanish Oloroso sherry casks.). It also carries an age statement of 14 years, which is respectable. The ABV is dipped a bit, to 43% and I believe it is chill filtered. This bottle retails for over $80. Thanks to my NJ whisky connection- Mr @PBMichiganWolverine for this generous pour.
The color is a beautiful, rich gold and it’s pretty oily. It leaves behind thin, watery legs and big drops after a spin in the Glencairn.
The nose is relatively light and malty, with orchard fruit and toffee candies. Honey and vanilla mingle with hints of cocoa powder and vine-ripened raspberries. It’s just that everything is on the lighter side and waiting it out doesn’t do much at all. The power level has been dialed way down.
The palate brings raisins and bitter chocolate out along with the fruits listed on the nose. It’s spicier and a bit more warming than I expected- especially for 43%. A zesty hint of citrus comes across the tongue late that really adds a bit of pep to the profile. The oily appearance isn’t felt on the tongue, though- it’s rather watery.
The finish is light and thin with woody apples and a faint alcohol note rounding things out. It’s also pretty short.
Overall, this strikes me as a beginner’s sherry whisky. Thin and weak are the key adjectives I take away from the total experience. It’s a typical, TRE mousetrap- lure you in with the Tamdhu name, the TRE exclusivity and slightly higher price tag, and drop the net on you once you get it home. Aka, it can be bested by lots of cheaper, sherried single malts and blends. I’ve had lots of good Tamdhu malts and this one doesn’t deliver the goods. Stick to first fill casks and higher ABV’s from them and you’ll be just fine- leave this one for the airport travelers and Tamdhu fanboys. 3 stars. Cheers.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
...So what would the Florida of scotches be?
@1901haha...agree 100%
@LeeEvolved sometimes I wish this app allowed liking of comments.
@Rick_M @LeeEvolved @Generously_Paul V Compass Box is definitely VS. Isnt JC Penny bankrupt? Tamdhu is more like Macy’s. You can buy the right stuff to make you look above your pay grade. I gotta say Ardbeg is like Frederick’s. Smoking hot, and just sooty dirty...but you love it anyway
@LeeEvolved - touché
@Rick_M - I would have to say that Compass Box is Victoria’s Secret. Sexy as hell and we all love the transparency.
@Generously_Paul - it’s the JC Penney’s of single malts. You can get the good stuff, sometimes on sale, but you don’t want your friends to know you’ve been there. GlenDronach is the Chick-fil-A fast food chain. It’s really the best, but too many damn people know it and go there.
@Generously_Paul - no, Rebel Yell! :)
@Rick_M Balvenie?
Where does Victoria’s Secret fit in all this?
If Macallan is Saks, that would make GlenDronach Macy’s, but I’ll be damned if Tamdhu is resigned to JC Penny. More like Nordstrom’s or Bloomingdales