Whiskey_Hound
Michter's US*1 Kentucky Straight Bourbon
Bourbon — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
May 25, 2019 (edited September 3, 2019)
The demand for this one has gotten quite high, and it's actually somewhat rare these days. When I finally found one, the price had jumped up to $45. Let's see if it's worthy of its new price tag.
Nose: Gala apple, brown sugar, shoe leather, oak spice, and black pepper. Especially oak and leather. Fairly standard bourbon notes, but it comes together very nicely in this one. Solid nose.
Palate: Caramel, vanilla, leather, oak spice, raisin, and black pepper. Prominent banana note. A bit of honey sweetness coupled with toffee and butterscotch. Big oak spice.
Finish: Moderate to long. It's all spice here: oak, cinnamon, nutmeg, black pepper. Nice way to cap off a fine pour.
This bottle improved greatly with time. It was barely a 3 star pour when I first cracked it. It's grown on me, and I'm glad for that. With that being said, there's nothing remarkable about this one either. The banana note is unique; it's much more pleasant here than it is in JD products.
Is the bump in price warranted? Well, considering that I've purchased Col. Taylor Small Batch and Old Ezra 7 for $45, I'd say this is hardly worth it. It doesn't hold a candle to either of those products. If we ignore that, it's a solid bourbon.
I had it pegged at 3.0 before this tasting (I'm more than 2/3 through), but it was surprisingly good this time around. Maybe this one takes well to oxidation, or maybe it's just my palate today. 3.5 seems right for this one.
45.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
I liked this one, but as you said, nothing special. Certainly not for the (then) price tag of $40. Not when I can get comparable bourbon for $25-$30. Gotta be something special or CS to get me to spend over $30 on bourbon anymore (Scotch is another story...). Great review!
@BDanner Completely agreed on the rye being the better of the two. I almost always lean toward the bourbon; this is one of those exceptions. I'm having a glass as I type this. Like you say, this one really benefits from a bit of time
I initially didn’t care for this one much either, but by the time I got around to reviewing it I gave it a decent score. Not as good as the rye, and definitely way back in the line of stuff I’d pay over $40 for.