LeeEvolved
Tamdhu Batch Strength Batch 001
Single Malt — Speyside , Scotland
Reviewed
July 16, 2019 (edited August 4, 2019)
Tamdhu has found a small place in my heart by offering very solid, sherry cask whisky for quite awhile now. My buddy @Generously_Paul would probably be considered the president of their fan club if such a thing existed. He’s also the reason I receive multiple pours of practically everything they release, so thanks for that my friend. I like to relate to Tamdhu as the discount sherry spot versus Macallan and even Glendronach. They offer similar quality usually at a better price.
This is their first NAS cask strength release, which has now grown to four subsequent releases, Batch Strength 001. Its NCF, no color added and bottled at 58.8% ABV. It’s amber and copper in color and makes skinny, oily legs and tiny droplets in your Glencairn when you take the time to rough it up in your glass before a tasting.
The nose is standard, Tamdhu sherry with newer smelling vibrant oak in the background. Time will release raspberry purée and a nutty, malty note that’s quite Macallan-esque. The heat blocks any more depth for me, I suspect because I refuse to add water to a 2oz sample. Other reviewers point out that you can go much deeper on the nose and palate if you dilute it to a proper 43-46%. I just don’t like to do that unless I have more whisky on hand, so perhaps next time.
The palate is initially like a peppered, sherry wine with cherries, vine-ripened berries, raisins and light citrus. I think I confused any identifying citrus characteristics with the higher heat from the ABV and the blast of oak from the casks used. Again, water is probably your friend here, but I’m a whisky snob and a jerk sometimes and refuse to invite the stuff into my Glencairn willingly. Surprisingly, though, there is a rich, full mouthcoat I don’t usually associate with cask strength whisky. So, that’s a plus.
The finish is long, spicy and hot with the predominant flavors being cherry and spiced oak. The youthful spirit is on display with a slight harshness that just wont quit, but I’m playing the whisky tough guy act and letting my eyes water a bit (or maybe it was that Sarah Mclachlan animal rescue commercial playing in the background- I’ll never tell, lol). Either way, a single tear ran down my cheek (1980’s anti-littering, Native American commercial style) before I brushed it away and chased the dram with a slug of bottled water. Yes, I’ll recycle said water bottle, my friends- I ain’t that heartless.
Overall, this is another fantastic cask strength bottle from Tamdhu. As I look back over my Batch 002 review, one thing caught my watery eyes- I didn’t get any dark chocolate notes like I did with that batch and for that reason I gotta conclude that Batch 001 isn’t quite as good as its successor. So, that said, this one is 3.75-4 stars, max. It’s good, but I think the second release is better. I’m about to try the Batch 003 soon- maybe they get better every time. Now that would be something worth getting emotional over. Cheers, and thanks for reading this one through.
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
Their Dalbealie batch 1 was amazing. I think batch 2 is out...not sure how that compares
@LeeEvolved Definitely agree on the A'Bundah and GF going down hill. Batch 55 of the AB was great stuff. As you say Tamdhu better vfm. So far I'd say the std 10 yeah has been my favourite.
@LeeEvolved thanks for the insights. Think it’s time to give Tamdhu a try.
@Whiskali - thanks for the vote of confidence. I remember the older batches of A’Bunadh really knocking my socks off. I think I’ve tried 4-5 different batches and they seem to indicate a downward trend in regards to overall taste and quality. It’s the same way with the Glendronach Cask Strength bottles IMHO. The Glenfarclas 105 is the epitome of value for money, although I did get my bottle on sale for a ridiculous price, but it lacks serious depth. I’d choose the Tamdhu over all 3, I think. It’s on par with the 2017 Macallan Classic Cut- I think that and the Tamdhu Batch 2 are almost interchangeable, with the Macallan being $10-ish more in price you do get name recognition and a little more clout. The drinker just needs to determine if that’s justified or necessary. Cheers.
@LeeEvolved another fantastic review! As noted in the latest Dapper Drams video, there’s a reason you’re distiller’s most popular reviewer. This one sounds a little better than the Virginia Lightning! :) How would you rank it against Aberlour a’bunadh and Glenfarclas 105?
Oh and I’m a member of the Tamdhu fan page on Facebook...there are many out there who put my enthusiasm to shame
I would rank the batch releases in this order 002, 003, 001. I’ll hopefully be opening 004 soon. They are all really good and drinkable for the strength.