Came back to the Bakers twice, as the1st time I had a Thomas H Handy 1st so the pour was muted. Def a good pour 4.25/ 5 Caramel Brown Sugar Vanilla Enough proof but not too much. I only drink neat & never add water to anything from 140+ proof on down. In today's environment ratings are more complicated if cost is factored in. So my rating is based on paying $100 - $120. As the price goes up rating goes to a 4. The bottle is very cool looking - I did not add anything in for the appearance but will look cool in any home bar