ScotchingHard
The Macallan Edition No. 1
Single Malt — Highlands, Scotland
Reviewed
March 26, 2020 (edited July 6, 2022)
Fuck you COVID and fellow humans, I have not seen Cottonelle on the shelves for weeks. Do you know how much a vintage 2020 Cottonelle is going to be worth at auction in a few years? There are no whiskies that are as analogous to my disappointment with the human race as the Macallan Edition series.
Around the time Macallan Ed 3 was being released, I still had 3 out-of-the-way small local liquor stores carrying edition 1 with probably about a dozen bottles on the shelves between them. I knew this edition was much less common than the celebrated edition 2, so I wound up buying 3 bottles, one at each store (because I have decency), at prices ranging from $105-120. I had no idea the secondary market was about to lose their shit for this whisky. I soon saw prices at online stores go above $500, and a friend was like, “Oh my god! You have edition 1?” So, I tried to go back to those stores to buy a bottle for him, and just like that, all 12 or so bottles had vanished.
I have an Instagram whisky account, I guess the hipsters shorten this to WhiskyGram, only because my wife wanted me on Instagram to compete with our dog’s account. My account is MaltyMemories, in case you’re interested. I’m not giving you my dog’s account, because she’s winning. I see accounts on Instagram with people showing off about a case of unopened Macallan Editions 1, 2, and even the later editions. People are snatching up editions 3, 4, and 5? Really? It is like snatching up Cottonelle toilet paper. I would like to have Cottonelle, but I’m not heartbroken buying Kirkland Signature. It’s toilet paper.
Macallan Edition series is toilet paper. I tried to convince myself that Edition 1 is the best, because it is the rarest, but let’s be honest, Macallan Edition 2 is the aloe-infused, extra-plush standout roll of toilet paper that gave celebrity to the series. Edition 2 had a sensible and realized purpose. Edition 1 is a bunch of different woods. In the end, this is slightly stronger Macallan 12 sherry oak circa 2014-15. Yeah, there’s more wood spices, if you’re into that thing. This is the most traditional Macallan of the Edition series, if you’re into that thing. But there’s also younger whisky that makes an unwelcomed appearance on the finish. And, in the end, it’s boring. Like Cottonelle, if unopened, you may have next month’s rent, if you can find a sucker; but, once opened, it’s just toilet paper.
Score: 0 (forgettable)
How much does a bottle cost: $800-2000+ on secondary market
How much do I think a bottle is worth: $100 (if you are planning to consume it).
105.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
For anyone interested, I just finished my latest video on this very subject. https://youtu.be/tJZ7iSDAjrk
@ScotchingHard one Mac Ed 1 will get you 4-5 bidets. Easily...
@ScotchingHard Ed 5 was worthy of trying simply because of how un-Macallan it is. Having said that, the palate was not good, Macallan or not
@PBMichiganWolverine @Generously_Paul My ranking goes 2 > 3 > 1 >4. Never tried 5. I opened 1 bottle and I still have 2 that I don't know what to do with. I need to look into Bidets. Mayble I can trade a Mac Ed 1 for a Bidet.
Haha good review as always! Ah I'm pretty sure the secondary market pricing is changing as I type!
@ScotchingHard you actually opened this???! It was the worst of the series.
@Rick_M man, once you go bidet, you never go back
@PBMichiganWolverine - are the new models still capable of washing the bathroom ceiling? My kids liked that feature in a few hotels we’ve stayed at. :)
I enjoyed editions 2-4. 5 was a disappointment. Way overpriced though, as is tradition with Macallan.
@Rick_M @ScotchingHard I have bidets. So glad I don’t have to arm wrestle someone for a cotenelle...
I think the Germans have the best toilet paper. It’s brown, it dispenses 1 sheet at a time like paper towels, it’s rupture proof, and it requires 3 times the number of plumbers in society to keep the pipes unclogged. Seems like a winning formula to me.