Another Whistlepig another satisfying experience. Not a fan of the strong peppermint flavour but really nice balance and all round delivery. Strip out the peppermint and you'd have a really top notch rye for me. All spice and cardamom were noted by others and yes they are the next most predominant flavours for me. As much as I dislike the peppermint (not as prominent in their Canadian version from memory), great quality. 4.25 for quality and 3.5 for flavour preference. 3.75 it is!