Blind tasting - 1.5 oz neat in a Glencairn - both bottles less than half full Maker's Mark Cask Strength Batch 19-02 (54.8%, open since March) vs. Larceny Barrel Proof A120 (61.6%, open since February) Color: Very similar medium amber, #B slightly darker Nose: A - Subtle baking spices, cinnamon and nutmeg. Some oak mixed with citrus peel, light caramel and sugar 6/10 B - Bready oak and ethanol, toffee, nutmeg, toasted vanilla bean 6/10 Palate: A - Oak and cherry, brown sugar, cinnamon bun, ethanol burn minimal 7/10 B - Cinnamon and nutmeg flavored shortbread, stewed or jam dark fruits, burnt caramel, palate quickly overpowered by ethanol burn 4.5/10 Finish: A - Tannic oak that lingers, medium oily finish, ethanol builds quickly 5/10 B - Strongly tannic and drying, long finish that burns, one-note flavor 3/10 Drinkability: A - 6.5/10 B - 4.5/10 Total score: A = 24.5/40 B = 18/40 A = Maker's Mark Cask Strength 19-02 B = Larceny Barrel Proof A120 I was surprised that I didn't really favor one nose over the other, despite there being clear differences. What sets them apart is the palate and finish. The Larceny BP runs hot, the ethanol and oak hit the tongue quickly overpowering other flavors and dominates the finish. It is slightly unpleasant, especially compared to the MMCS. For me the Larceny is less complex and harsher to drink.