Still extremely good (Scene 5) but not as epic as the other version I've tried. Aroma is nice and has both spice notes of Rye but also deep baking spices and dark fruit. Opened up nicely Mint, berry, all spice and lots of Rye notes in the flavor. Couple drops of water were nice and kicked up the spice. I'll continue to look for this Rye and it's a favorite.