LouisianaLonghorn
Old Forester Rye
Rye — Kentucky, USA
Reviewed
August 13, 2020 (edited November 7, 2020)
Time to continue our American whiskey summer. I've avoided rye for years; never quite reconciling it's flavor profile with my preferences. With my recent return to bourbon, I've decided to explore the ryes offered by some of my favorite bourbon distilleries. We'll start with Old Forester, and you'll see some other offerings from Wild Turkey down the line here.
This is a new rye offering from Old Forester, which makes some of my favorite bourbon on the planet. They're reviving an old, old rye mashbill that Brown-Foreman acquired from another distillery they bought on their way to world domination. What makes this unique is that after the rye in the mashbill (around 62%), the next highest grain is malted barley at around (17%), with the remainder being corn. That ought to create a unique profile for any American spirit. What's in this one?
The nose is softer than it is spicy. Already different from many ryes. The black pepper is present, but not in your face. If you're an experienced single malt drinker, you'll detect the barley sugars and maltiness on the nose, almost like Whoppers candy. No hint of the proof, despite the relatively high ABV. A fine start.
It hits your tongue and BAM it explodes with flavors with the force of rocketing down a water slide. There's cherry, allspice, clove, semi-sweet chocolate, ginger, spearmint, and a hint of cinnamon. This all leads into a gentle, warming finish that lingers for a long time on the palate due to the proof, though at no point is it harsh or astringent. It's also oily and mouth coating due to the high barley content. Repeated visits to the glass bring out more cherry on the nose and more notes of toffee and graham cracker in the palate. What a ride!
This is good rye. Bordering on great. Did I mention that this is around $25 MSRP? At that price this is a must buy. I can also report that it's versatile in mixed drinks (best old fashioned I've made so far in quarantine) and on ice (because Texas summer). I've had ryes that cost 3X what this does that I like a whole lot less. It packs a wallop of flavor and complexity for an almost criminal price. Highly recommend. Cheers!
25.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@jonwilkinson7309 That sounds terrific! I quite liked the Corsair Ryemageddon, which is also very chocolatey, so it sounds like a great one for me to try :)
@ContemplativeFox. Balcones rye is... Balcones. Thick and rich and bold. It's unmistakably rye, but there's a great chocolate/mocha note front and center. Different, but great stuff. I like Balcones in general, but IMO, this is one of their best
@BeppeCovfefe thanks good sir. Good to hear from you. I’ve got a bottle of Russell’s Reserve SiB rye based on your recommendations coming up next!
Certainly a rich and great value rye, I always have a warm feeling of security seeing this on the shelf for under 28$
@runrevcollins it’s certainly one of the best deals out there right now. Cheers friend.
Thanks for such a detailed review. That sounds like a beautiful sipper.
This is my favorite OldFo (maybe second to 1920?) and a close second to Rittenhouse in value rye. Both are insanely good for about $25.
@Ctrexman thanks as always!
@bigwhitemike many thanks!
@jonwilkinson7309 I agree that the Balcones rye is different. That chocolate note really stands out on that one. I’ve almost been forcing myself to try more rye this summer, similar to the way I learned to drink black coffee when I was 15. Just do it enough and one develops a palate for it. I’m starting to appreciate Kentucky rye a lot more. Still don’t care for the MGP rye, but I’ve always liked Canadian rye.
@jonwilkinson7309 I wasn't aware that Balcones has a really exceptional rye. What makes it so good?
This is great value and very tasty agreed, nice review
@jonwilkinson7309 It's not barrel proof, only 100 proof
Appreciate the review! I've generally not been drawn to ryes either (with the exception of Balcones, but that's quite different). But I'm a big OF fan as well, and $25 for barrel proof?? Wow.
Dang, cool mashbill, 50% ABV, $25 MSRP. I need to just get a bottle so I can taste it again. Fantastic tasting notes by the way - I love the additional information you provided!
Agree 100%. Great review, great product.