Tastes

4/13/22 bought this in Marquette, MI for $69.99. Was very disappointed to read that this was sourced. However, this might be in its favor. I tried the 86 proof standard at a local bar and wasn’t too impressed. This barrel proof is a different story… The nose is Mrs Butterworth’s pancake syrup. Warm brown sugar, hints of honey. Caramel and very little astringent ethanol. Taste is similar, but less syrup influence. More traditional bourbon flavors. Caramel, vanilla, Swiss cake rolls? A touch of nuttiness but faint. Finish is subtle. I’m surprised by how little the proof hits. No burn. Oak, faint popsicle stick. More honey. Short flavorful finish. I don’t regret spending $70 on this, but I don’t think I would buy it again. I would’ve spent $70-80 and buy the “Starlight bourbon finished in Maple” if I can find it. Much better overall, and it’s their own distillate.

Outstanding. This is the third Private Selection I’ve had. This is a 0-3-2-5-0 and the 5 French Mocha staves really impart a lovely hot chocolate/mocha cappuccino flavor in addition to the normal caramel/vanilla/cinnamon flavors.

Store pick from Aman’s Liquor in Wind Lake, Wi. His palate really matches mine. He does excellent barrel picks and I’ve loved them all. Excellent nose. Dark fruit, maple syrup. Palate matches nose. Sweet caramel, raisins, cinnamon toast, syrupy waffles, Medium finish, not too dry. More spice hits after the swallow. Pleasant burn. I want more!