Barrell Foundation Bourbon

I've had several Barrell Products now. They're all well reviewed. Afficionados seems to love them, and I've enjoyed them, but they're overrated. Yes, I said it. O VER RA TED. I always feel the need to explain when I use that word that overrated does not mean bad. They're not synonyms. Overrated means people are saying it's better than it actually is. I've read 5-10 reviews that are glowing of Barrell Foundation, and again, it's not bad, but I got it for $50 on sale, $5 off, and it's not worth that price. With Knob Creek 9 on the market for around $40, with Dickel BiB around for $44, with 1792 BiB around for $40, these are all at the same proof, all more aged, and all, frankly, more dynamic, I see no need being filled by a $55 Barrell 5-Year. That said, it's not bad, but if they could price it $15 less, I might be more inclined to buy. Truth told, it's unique from what I've mentioned above. Dickel BiB is chocolate cherry. 1792 is vanilla, nuts and spice. This one is fruity in an orchard fruit type way. Pear, apple. You do get caramel and vanilla, which runs along many bourbons. There's a sweetness here that transcends the sweetness of those others, which if you're into that is great. But honestly, Old Tub, well, while I can't say it's better it's also only $20-$25. I guess what I'm saying is that the aroma and taste of Barrell Foundation is just not unique enough to justify the cost. That's the main drawback here. Why am I paying this much for a 100 proof whiskey that doesn't stand out from other 100 proof whiskies that are cheaper? I don't know. Can you tell me?

Nose: Some caramel on the nose. Definitely some alcohol bite. A vague note that smells like seagrass. Palate: Burns very quickly, especially on the tongue. Very heavy mouthfeel, and it hangs out at the top.of your mouth. There is a slightly sweet peanuts note. Not the dustyness of Jim Beam, but still there. Finish: The bourbon loses most of its taste going down. The burn disappates quickly and then it just feels quite cold down the back of your throat. Some fruit appears on the tail end. Overall, for the price, I was disappointed. With ice, this is a decent bourbon, and it works as an "unwind at the end of the day" drink. However, for $45-$55, I can 100% find better bourbons out there.

Nose: Notes of maple syrup and honey immediately come to mind. Palate: Nice coating of the tongue with more maple syrup, tasted marshmallows, with a touch of dark chocolate and leather. Lots going on here. Overall: This could be my favorite bang for the buck out there!

Pretty easy going for 100 proof. Overall enjoyable and would buy again.