Requested By
visvarupa
Kilchoman Machir Bay
-
Ctrexman
Reviewed January 21, 2023 (edited February 19, 2023)This comes off a little thin but is loaded with flavor. Plenty of smoky vanilla, animal crackers, fresh creamy malt plus the beach. Salt and surf but no sand in your shoes. This is a winner as are all their offerings. No age statement but no matter its great stuff. Similar to the Bunna peated has a nice richness.........bumping to 4 stars..90/10057.0 USD per Bottle -
jimmyjam312
Reviewed December 30, 2022 (edited June 13, 2023)Review #001 Tasted after: first up Appearance (no score): • Light golden color • Swirling reveals a thick line sticking to the side of the glass, legs are slow to form Nose: 17/20 • All BBQ up front, sweet and not spicy, some sea spray and a little charcoal also Palate: 36/50 • Smokey and briny with a hint of lemon • Good but a little underwhelming after the appearance and nose Finish: 15/30 • Almost non-existent, brief hint of charcoal and a short ethanol burn Total: 68/100 • Scoring rubric 55-69: Drinkable • 2.75-3.5 stars Final thoughts: • Worth trying but I won’t be replacing this bottle once it’s gone • A drop of water brings out big vanilla up front but it struggles to mesh well with the other flavors, and increases the saltiness of the finish Price: $60 Would recommend: no Would buy: no60.0 USD per Bottle -
caluja
Reviewed December 26, 2022Never been much for smokey whiskies, but this is one of the better ones. I consider it medium smokey compared to others I’ve tried. In short, enjoyable periodically.90.25 CAD per Bottle -
Mtower
Reviewed December 21, 2022My first peaty whiskey I don’t absolutely hate, might have something to do with the bourbon and sherry finish Wise Old Dog barrel pick -
NickiT
Reviewed December 12, 2022Nose: Citrus, vanilla, soft smoke Palate: Raisins, fruits, peat smoke Finish: Fruits, hint of pepper, soft smoke Tasty, fruity and peaty 7/10
Results 101-110 of 252 Reviews