Requested By
bulletproofwelding
Murray Hill Club special release
-
mec1919
Reviewed December 18, 2019 (edited October 15, 2020)with just a bit more richness to fill out the middle, this would be an absolute top notch bourbon. even as is, it’s a great drink: good amount of dry oak, great sweetness. the flavor doesn’t shrink with food either.Levitate Gastropub -
dhsilv2
Reviewed August 23, 2019 (edited September 1, 2020)Release batch 2. Bottle 586/700 Open for about 7-9 months. "This blended bourbon would be about 18 to 20% of a 9 year old light whiskey, with the majority of the blend being 12 year old bourbon, followed by some 19 year old bourbon to give it more depth and complexity. " From Nancy herself on this batch 2 blend. Of course I'll leave out the notes on the wine finish, well beyond me wheel house to discuss. OK so color has that dark old bourbon note. A touch cloudy perhaps even, very viscous. Nose - rich, dusty, I get a lot of cognac notes, and yet there's a white sweet note. Once opened - huge vanillas, tobacco, oak, leather, and that white sweet note from the finishing. Taste - Rich, oaky, dry, yet has a sweet over tone. Rich sweetness, coating the mouth, it's really good. I remember this being better when i first opened it up. The pineau des charentes casks are really one dimensional at this point. Sweet, long, lingering but not really adding what I recall. The bottle is still past the half way point, it seems this bottle doesn't oxidize well. That said I'm still giving this 4 stars. It's really great bourbon but it's missing out on complexity to push it higher and the 160 price is well out of line for most bourbon drinkers.160.0 USD per Bottle -
whiskysinmyring
Reviewed August 4, 2019 (edited August 12, 2020)Sweeter nose than straight, little smoother tongue. Lighter mouthfeel, still a little oily. A little water adds creaminess and a little burn, doesn’t dull the nose (Joseph Magnus bottling). -
BourbonLuvr
Reviewed February 13, 2019 (edited October 2, 2022)While not inexpensive, it's still less than $100 if you can find it for retail and not on the secondary market. More importantly, this pour is nothing short of amazing with its strong caramel, vanilla notes and deceitful ABV, as it's very smooth without a lot of heat...highly recommend drinking neat...enjoy!!95.0 USD per Bottle -
whiskey_whisky_
Reviewed January 12, 2019Good base, with a unique finish. Batch 2. 2018 A few years later, opened up my second bottle of Batch 2. Nice nose, pleasant, sweet... almost un-whiskey like. A bit of a funky note at the end. On the palate, sweet right off the bat. Some tea, some cinnamon, some honey. Unique finish. Just as good as I remember. Better than Batch 3. 10/9/20
Results 11-19 of 19 Reviews