The Macallan Edition No. 1

12/30/17 - $103.99 off the shelf. The nose on this is amazing. Vanilla, sweet, really amazing. It’s too bad the taste falls flat. It hits your mouth with a rich feeling, but none of the nose is present. Spicy and dry, it finishes with a little smoke and falls flat. Based on what this sells for on the secondary market, I’m shocked there wasn’t more to this. It’s good, it’s a very good Macallan... but doesn’t live up to the expectations I had based on Edition #3. 3.5/5

Uber sweet on the nose of caramel citrus, cherry. The initial flavors lack the expectation from the nose though. Sweet vanilla, and honey in the middle, but thins quickly. Does not live up the type of the talk. A little disappointing to say the least.