Whiskey_Hound
Lagavulin 16 Year
Single Malt — Islay, Scotland
Reviewed
April 11, 2021 (edited June 2, 2021)
This one needs no introduction. When I first joined Distiller, I reviewed this is an about 20 words. Now I'd like to do it better justice.
Nose: Usual suspects. Rich peat and campfire smoke. Some brine and salinity, with a touch of seaweed and iodine. Apple, orange, and lemon, and blue raspberry. Vanilla cream and caramel. Smoked meat with some baking spices. Black pepper and cinnamon. Roasted nut and oak. Solid nose as always.
Palate: Layers of peat and campfire smoke. The saline notes are now accompanied by some earthier peat. Apple and heaps of blue raspberry flavor. Vanilla, caramel, and mixture of milk and dark chocolate. Citrus and agave. Some black bean red pepper chili adds just a little spice. More roasted nut and nice hit of oak.
Finish: Ashy, sulfuric peat and campfire smoke. Sea salt, citrus, and blue raspberry, again. Black bean red pepper chili hit on the final waves of what makes for a medium-length finish.
My initial Distiller review for this was 5-stars. I'd award the same rating to most Lag 16 pours I've had at bars and wherever else. This particular bottle, however, is missing something that the rest had. It's still great, but something important is definitely absent.
This bottle recently underwent a price increase. This particular bottle is a step below any other bottle of Lag 16 I've ever had. This is a revision of a 5-star review--I gave it the benefit of the doubt a dropped it a quarter-star. That is subject to further revision. For better or for worse.
There are bad bottles in every batch. I won't rule that out. But it is concerning that I paid a good chunk extra for this, and it's not as good as I remember. Like I said, I gave this the benefit of the doubt. I will update this review as I finish the bottle, and I will inevitably buy another to confirm this wasn't an off-bottle. As for this review, I'm factoring in all of my previous experiences with Lag 16, and while I'm being hyper-critical of this one, it's only because I hold this one in the highest regard. 4.75.
78.0
USD
per
Bottle
Create Account
or
Sign in
to comment on this review
@Whiskey_Hound haha, notice I’m not wagering any money on optimism. Wishes in one hand and all...
@bigwhitemike I hope you’re right on this one but my cynicism leads me to go with @WhiskeyLonghorn on this one lol
@BDanner NC is a control state, right? Maybe with the state exerting more pressure on bulk pricing you’ll see your prices come down sooner than here in free market everything TX.
@WhiskeyLonghorn Lagavulin 16 has returned to pre-tariff MSRP here (back to $99 from $126). However, All Laphroaig is still at tariff pricing ($20+ over old MSRP).
@WhiskeyLonghorn lol, that’s fair. I do think the market coming flush with soooo many new options/distilleries/styles/production capacities will help boomerang things back around at some point, despite all these things coming at a much increased MSRP. Supply is quickly catching up to demand no matter what the Buffalo Trace chasers would have you believe, but we’ll have to see how long that arc is.
@bigwhitemike I wouldn’t put it past the bloodsuckers at Diageo to keep the prices where they are tariffs or no tariffs. A chance to boost their bottom line at the expense of unwitting American consumers seems too diabolical for them to pass up...
Lag16 for 78 bones is quite the steal these days - typically this is over 100 by me. Hopefully the tariffs unravel in the retail prices at some point, and the whiskey boom starts to mean supply outpaces demand and we can all pick what we like for an appropriate price again.