This bottle was very meh for me. When you smell fragrant apple and spices, you think this is going to be incredible. After tasting, the apple comes through but not as intense as the smells gives off. The baking spices take the lead with heavy cardamom, clove, butter and oak. The finish aside from being oily doesn't last. Solid bottle but nothing to scream praise of. I'll try again just to confirm because I wanted more of the apple.