Classic spicy rye nose with strong perfumey floral notes (violets) I’ve come to expect with previous Whistle Pig bottlings. Flavor is spicy vegetal and alcohol heavy with some mint, again a signature trait. There is an ashy taste on the finish. Water sweetens the nose and reveals more complexity with a strong citrus and wall-plaster thing dominating. Flavor however becomes bland and muted. This is a big loser for me. Some interesting things happen on the nose, but the flavor is desperately wanting.