Tastes

Selected by Premium Wine and Spirits, barrel #605, barreled on 03FEB2017. Nice tattoo photo. A lovely gift from a family member for Christmas, someone who knows I'm a sucker for single barrel selects. While creating a standard single barrel select entry for Distiller (the specificity allowed on here always astonishs me), I found out that there are a lot of stated age selections on the Clyde May's brand, something that I definitely consider rare from the American whiskey industry. After reading the incredibly busy and eye-straining label front-to-back, I confirmed that this bottle has a barreled date, but not a bottled date, which is sketchy even with the 5 year age statement; if you're going to put this much detail on your label, you might as well include all the logistics instead of just some. Also, having already not heard great things about the Clyde May's line, I'm now even more scared to try it after learning it comes out of Bloomington, but I'll give benefit of the doubt up front despite having drunk the water there. A slightly darker color than expected, instead being as dark as a 6 or 7 year bourbon, but it does appear the oak is fairly heavily charred by color alone. A fairly potent ethanol up front, followed by fresh cherry, cinnamon, spearmint, a slight mixed fruit (with an emphasis on banana), as well as vanilla and toasted oak. A standard nose that hints to a high rye blend, but also showcases enough of the younger corn without being too young all around. A little dry up front, but does start to coat the gums fairly quickly, although doesn't penetrate that deeply. Definitely a fair amount of rye on board, but the corn is teetering between a younger, fresher flavor and the broken down, sweeter body of a slightly aged distillate. All of the notes from the nose are present and tasted, with more barrel present that presents some sweet but turns fairly dry on the finish. Only after some air and a few minutes does a decent hit of rye move into the finish to spice things up. Overall, a fairly plain but still tasty bourbon, with nothing special to offer other than the difference between the barrels, of course. Not to discredit it or to say I wouldn't want to try different barrels, but it certainly affects the price point, and since I didn't buy it, I can only say that I would only be comfortable purchasing this at $55 or below, and no more. Still, it's a versatile bourbon that can be used in any manner, neat, mixed, or anywhere in between, and will be tasty while also simple without pause.

I am very happy to have rediscovered this whiskey, as I missed an opportunity to buy it several years ago while traveling and felt regret ever since. I've had it somewhere at a tasting longue, but don't recall anything that's worth remembering. Even still, the reason I remain excited and hopeful is simply because of this being a Canadian product, since some of the most quality rye grain comes out of the Canada. The country is big enough and I am ignorant enough that I don't know which regions grow the "best" rye, what those differences might be, and if there even are major differences, but I do know that some of the best rye whiskeys I've had have either been from Canada, or distilled elsewhere using Canadian rye grain. Adding to that fact that this is cask strength and a 100% rye mashbill gives me very high hopes that I hope the flavor can live up to. At an impressive 127.4 proof and the lack of added water after leaving the barrel, I'm a bit shocked at how light the color is, especially since charred barrels are used. In the end, I'm guessing this is due to a very short time in the barrels overall, or perhaps a very light char level used. Despite this, the nose is very simplistic and yet creates an air of a very full body. Notes of caramel and familiar wood sugars tell me the barrel did impart plenty here, but is balanced well alongside freshly cracked rye grain, with notes of spicy cinnamon and a floral background, but closer to grass than anything blooming. Not quite the best balance of sweet and spicy that I've encountered, but by smell alone, it's definitely very close to the top. Intially in the mouth, the sweetness leads the way, specifically with caramel and basic sugar, not quite flavorful enough to be wood sugar. The spicy notes come through with some air in the form of the familiar cinnamon, but doesn't penetrate very far into the gums like I would have expected of both the grain and proof. A strange flavor amalgam begins to surface near the finish, almost like that of a charcoal tinge, but not as aggressive. Thinking on it more along with a few more sips, my guess is that I may be tasting some of the unique minerality that could be present in the mountain water that was used. This isn't quite off-putting, especially if you continue to refresh the palate with continued sips; this is notably easy because, even with half the glass gone, the ABV isn't potent enough to slow tasting. There's one thing that I've learned for certain when tasting Canadian rye whiskeys versus whiskeys made using Canadian rye: every Canadian-distilled whiskey has been highly unique. In the case of this one, my assumption of the specific water used delivers a finish unlike any other rye whiskey, despite the immediate and intermediate flavors still being fairly predictable. A good representation of the "Great White North," but definitely outside the bounds of being worth it for the price, especially because the proof isn't that impressive as far as tasted than one would think at this high a level.

I'm not usually one to create a new listing for batched whiskey (while some others will create listings for far less of a change), but this one does have a different ABV listed, and the distillery found it important enough to print new labels with this information instead of using write-in labels, so here we are. At least I take better pictures than damn near everyone else on here. A darker color from some decent time in the barrel around the outskirts of the glass, but a surprisingly thin and more translucent hue through the center. Lots of classic notes on the nose, including vanilla and wood sugar, but there are also some smaller notes of unripe banana, and some citrus-y grain. The ethanol is really quite weak through the nose given the proof. The body is a little weak at first, but it's mostly because the focus is simple, and really captures good, basic qualities of a bourbon. The corn is still young, but at it's full strength, it combines well with the small amount of rye here, giving a sweetness that has just a tinge of bitterness behind it thanks to the charred barrels. The gum piercing is mild, but the rye can still be tasted in the forms of cinnamon and some of the raw grain, again with the youngness. A slight spiciness on the finish, but far than I expected with this proof, which is interesting as well as it is dangerous. I really do love the simplicity that Bulleit captures, being a bourbon that's very approachable by all, and, as a side note, for making the most rounded and first (to me) proper 95% rye whiskey. As that stands, that also makes this a very approachable cask strength bourbon, but also makes it fairly plain as a result. For the price, it's a great pick-up, and although I don't believe there can be too much of a difference between batched whiskey, it's cheap enough to get a few of the different batches and work to detect the nuances between them. Other than that, as I continued to finish my glass, I was unable to come up with any further notes, further sinking in the simplicity of this whiskey, for better or worse.

Holy shit do I love Metallica. Seriously, likely my favorite metal or heavy rock band of all time. I do have the classic Blackened whiskey, but it's definitely not my flavor profile, and is a little weak for my tastes. When this one came out a few months ago (near my birthday), I do not have shame in saying that I begged a lot of people to get this for me as a gift. That did not happen, mostly because the pre-orders sold out almost immediately (why does nobody budget the correct amount of whiskey for pre-orders?), and it was far overpriced. Thankfully, I found it locally for far less, and I definitely couldn't resist. As I listen to the Ride the Lightning album (well, I cheat and am listening to the Call of Ktulu version with San Francisco Symphony Orchestra because it's amazing), I will enjoy this no matter what, because Metallica kicks ass and a rye is always better for me. There's lots of fresh rye grain on the nose, with an impressive spiciness for the relatively low proof. Candied cinnamon and a bit of citrus pop out, with the classic cut grass behind it. A great amount of caramel is also present, which I am guessing comes from the triple barreling of sorts. A light body is what starts off, but the rye grain is present with a sweeter flavor, likely from the rum barrel. There's also a very dry follower, which I attribute to the wine barrels. The gum penetration is moderate here, and the spice level is also moderate, but only because the flavors imparted by the barrels also deliver to an almost equal amount. The finish is pretty hot, but it ultimately ends with a dry finish, which does keep you coming back for more, to refresh the cycle. Maybe it's the music playing (very loudly) behind me, or because this whiskey is both delicious and unique, but I'm quite enjoying this. It's definitely not a front runner of any of my rye favorites, but it also isn't entirely in the rye category, since the Madeira and rum deliver their own flavor notes that definitely do come through. For ~$70, this is way steep, but if this ever dropped below $50, this would easily be both the most metal and layered rye whiskey out there, and created with no other method that can be rivaled by any other distillery, similar to how Metallica cannot be rivaled in their music; if there is such a rival, I definitely need to crank those tracks.

Liquor Barn barrel select, barrel #2675, bottle #59, barreled December 2015, bottled May 2021, 50.5% ABV. Finally, I found a single barrel of this rye. I have been to the distillery over most of the summer asking about a single barrel rye, and was left to drink whatever else sounded good at the bar while planning my next trip in this search. This distillery has always been a little "off" to me, and it wasn't until writing this review that I think I've figured out why. Usually American distilleries will start "side project" distilleries once they become successful, sometimes as a friendly competition, to double profits, or just to experiment in different spirits or climates, usually done so in different countries. In the case of Town Branch, THEY are actually the experiment, with the "sister distillery" in Europe actually being the flagship safe route. Either way, the new rye whiskey in the square bottle is miles improved from the tall bottle with rounded shoulders, and having finally found a single barrel, I'd love to see exactly where the flavors travel. A typical dark caramel color of a rye whiskey aged this long, but still slightly darker than the batched version of this same whiskey. Sweet molasses and bold cinnamon battle it out on the nose, with the outcome being a malty, spicy confusion of scents in the end. I'm trying to ignore the abysmal low amount of rye in the mash bill, but the sweet corn on the nose makes it very difficult to do so. Hoping this doesn't turn out to be a bad barrel, since I do enjoy the batched version just fine. Yikes. The flavor is full of spicy malt, like this were some kind of single malt whiskey with some capsaicin added. Low rye is one thing, but just barely over legal requirements for rye is embarrassing, and the flavor really shows that. Even the gum burn leaves so much to be desired, and trying to reach by applying some air only makes the sugary sweetness of the corn stronger, truly making me forget that I'm even drinking rye whiskey. Despite the malty sweet finish, after enough time, there is enough rye left in the air and gums to not be a hateful attempt at a proper rye whiskey. For the life of me, I don't know how the standard batched rye whiskey, that I had just a few weeks ago at most, can be this many galaxies away in taste just because it's one barrel. A shame really, but it makes me happy that it didn't cost very much, and I still have something to add to my barrel pick section regardless. Still, this was definitely regretful how much time was spent searching for this, and had I remembered how low the rye percentage was initially, I may have stopped the search, but the call for barrel picks, and at this price point, means I still would likely have picked it up anyway.