Whiskey night October - enjoying an evening on the porch with a friend, a fire pit, a few blind tastings and a few new bottles. All samples from a Norlan glass.
Tasting order:
Murray Hill Club, Batch 7
The Gifted Horse, Orphan Barrel
*Larceny Barrel Proof, A120
Lux Row Double Barrel 12y
Garrison Bro. Cowboy Bourbon, 2019
Blinded pour #2. How can this be?? My nose completely deceived me... at first I could swear there was rye bread and clove. I never would have guessed what I was drinking!
Color: Medium amber with sparse, medium speed legs.
Nose: Tons of brown sugar, rye bread, clove, possibly pralines.
Body: Medium to heavy, coating, building warmth but not bite and warm finish in the chest. Mildly drying.
Palate: Flavors galore. Up front some vanilla frosted cinnamon roll, clove, brown sugar and then a transition to round 2 with some earthy tea/tobacco and mint Tums before flipping back to toffee sweetness and pumpkin pie spice on the finish.
Finish: This was a 3-course meal! Nice evolution of flavor profiles and a coating, satisfying finish for over a minute.
Verdict - the first time I saw this it is a price tag of ~$100. Needless to say I passed but knowing what I know now there would be no hesitation in grabbing one at that price. Would be steep (but easily justifies $80 in today’s market) and is an absolute steal at the $50 MSRP.
I can’t believe this is a wheated mashbill either. At first I thought this would be a high-rye MGP and still can’t understand how this batch is remotely related to 92 proof Larceny. I’ve been humbled for sure!!