I'm not sure if I found the nose complex or just too much happening at once. Aromas of everything from peaches to maple to apples. Taste is about the same---just too much happening, and to some extent losing the classic Oban profile. Between this and the 14, I'd choose the 14. Especially considering the minimal price difference. Update 3/18: I had this as a sample, this time with some ice. Better than neat, but still prefer the 14. Thanks to Ryan for the sample!