Tastes

Actually a big fan of this easy sipping whisky for a reasonable price. For the big name blends, it's either this or Johnny Black for me. Nothing special, but no complaints either.

Not impressed. Many better options for the same price.

Everyday stuff at an everyday price. You know what you are gettin every time, and there is something to be said for that.

Truly quite delicious and enjoyable, but... I didn't find anything in this whisky that stood out to justify its price tag or mystique. I'd drink it all day in somebody else's tab, but there are plenty of things I'd rather try instead if I'm footing the bill.

The most enjoyable if the island malts I have tried. Excellent balance and interesting flavored. The view from the top of the Hancock building don't hurt either.

When I tried this, I'm not sure my palate was ready for the complexity and peat this brings to the table. I was only able to enjoy it after a second round of cubes were allowed to dilute the stuff. My guess would be that if I were to have it again as my taste has been refined, I would be more open to the campfire by the sea experience that it offers. UPDATE: As I suspected, after a few years away, my second experience was significantly better. A room temp neat pour = sweet smoke. Very sweet, actually. quite enjoyable, and a juxtaposition found uniquely in an islay Scotch. Fruity and floral with notable salty/sea notes. Nose is all smoke and sea. Very smooth with no burn at all.

Very good and amazingly rich for a 12 year, but not quite a standout for the price point. Would be the best $45 bottle, but is only a solid competitor for its asking price. Rich, creamy texture. Gentle sweetness. Mild saltwater with fruit rind.

Rich, smooth, complex. Best I've ever tasted. Hopefully that changes some day without making me a poor man in the process, but for now, it is the benchmark and gold standard.

A rockstar. Sweet and approachable, but don't mix this with a soda unless you're in the mood for syrup. That being said, this is incredibly affordable as a longstanding staple that predates the bourbon boom. Revisited. Really impressive smoothness when neat. Upped rating to 4 stars. Great bourbon for the price. I see why the weller products stand out - a very unique palate. Minty and herbal, in a very pleasant way. Only the mildest menthol burn. Excellent and affordable wheated bourbon.

Fine in your average meat market bar with coke, but I it's only a go-to for people that don't care enough to actually explore the world of whiskey. Save your liver for something far more impressive.