Tastes

Smooth, excellent. I can't tell much difference between the triple and double. They are similar.

Excellent, smooth, you can't go wrong with a Macallan in my opinion.

Expensive, flavorful like the Valknut, but not as smooth or as peaty as the 12 and 18. The 12 and 18 are far superior, but I enjoy this one a lot. The price is high because it's from a single cask. Money would be better spent on the 18 year or the Valknut (similar taste, similar bite, but a lot more affordable.)

More flavorful than the 12, but I probably prefer the 12 over this. It's definitely one of my favorites though.

Delicious, smooth. The only downside is a wish it was slightly more peaty, but otherwise it's perfect.

Sweet, but not as complex as the 16 (which makes sense.)

Excellent. Got this is as a gift and it's one of my favorites. Nice smokey punch in the face, but also sweet and pleasant taste.

Was gifted this for my birthday. I really enjoyed this 10 year. When compared with Laphroaig's 10, I thought this had more flavor. It's slightly less smoky and a little sweeter than Laphroaig.

Really good and smooth for a 10. It’s a good replacement for Lagavulin if your budget is smaller. I was surprised at how good this 10 year was. It’s smoky and peaty right up front which is nice (though I prefer the light peakiness of Highland Park).

Sweet, but not overly. Overall it’s very nice to sip. It’s smooth and has a good amount of flavor. I was hoping for something close to the Glenmoragie Nector Dor but this doesn’t quite line up. There’s a sweetness Nector Dor has that I haven’t been able to match. This reminds me of Aberlour 16 but it doesn’t have any of the floral taste Aberlour 16 has which makes it better to me (I’m not a fan of the floral taste.)