Cornmuse
Reviewed
July 3, 2023 (edited August 13, 2023)
A gift from a visiting friend, this is my first experience with this distillery. Tasted neat from a NEAT tasting glass after a few moments rest. I've had this on a few occasions already and the bottle is about 2/3 full after this pour. It's been open for about a month.
The pour is a very pale apple juice brassy color, painfully clear. The nose is all in on the apples with strong notes of sweet apple juice, tart apple skins, green apples, red delicious apples, green pears, slight lemon, lemongrass, slight grain and almost no ethanol note. This is very, very complex and also very dainty and delicate. After a while there's just the slightest hint of ash and an ephemeral note of something resembling mercurochrome.
I'm loving this complexity while the whisky never becomes overpowering. Very impressive.
On the palate this maintains its delicacy. There is a sweet blush of butter and honey up front that quickly dissolves into an assortment of orchard fruits, primarily Honeycrisp apple, green pears, green tea, and graham crackers. As the flavor begins to fade there's a nice transition to ginger, allspice and finally cracked pepper. The finish is moderate, fading cleanly to a lemony tartness with a bit of the bitter lemon pith left on the back of the tongue.
I don't have a lot of experience with Japanese whisky. I've had Toki (not a fan), Nikka Grain (quite nice if ultimately a bit too reticent to hold my attention), Nikka From the Barrel (yes, please), Yamazaki 12 (I remember liking it but I don't remember specifics about it) and this. If this is typifies an excellent Japanese whisky, then I've done myself a disservice by not paying more attention to the category.
Taken on its own this is a top tier distillate, full stop.
I use a simple grading system based on bell curve distribution. Mass market quality product (Beam, JD, Woodford, Dewar's) will hover between 2 and 3. Truly good product emerges at 3.5 and above 4 are the stand-out products that offer unique tasting adventure balanced with a reachable price point. This is such a whisky.
This is absolutely above average. Well above average, in fact.