nikbuys
Reviewed
January 21, 2026 (edited February 18, 2026)
Comparing with Càirdeas 2024 Cask Favorites to see how Pedro Ximenez influence interacts in each release. PX is noticeably much darker and reddish/maroon in hue while Cask Favorites is more a rose gold.
Nose: rich, sweet, spicy. Sticky/syrupy dark and dried fruits. Craisin, dried plum/cherry, dried vanilla bean and baking spice. Earthy sherry. A touch of charred oak. Strong salinity, coastal/maritime peat fire.
--The 2024 Càirdeas in comparison is noticeably more vanilla and charred oak forward, but still retaining a nice element of the sticky PX influence.
Palate: dark, sweet, fruity with a nice underlying robust medicinal and phenolic Laphroaig peat. Black cherry, dried dark fruits, a bit of a dark mixed berry/currant jam. A touch of vanilla and nice overall Christmas spice character.
Drying tannic charted oak and bitter cacao as it transitions to finish.
--Càirdeas 2024 has a noticeably stronger cinnamon/spice element as well as vanilla and more robust oakiness.
Finish: the peat really shines here, ashy, phenolic and with a nice strong salty sea spray. Charred oak warmth here too.
-- Càirdeas '24 remains spicier and more warming, much more oak, less maritime character on the finish. A bit more dark chocolate.