Old Pulteney 12 Year

Solid whisky. A little fruit on the nose, full, rich mouthfeel. Heavy, oily spirit, but well put together on the palate. Medium length finish. Would buy again.

Older bottle, 43%, in the tube. This is awesome and $30-35 a bottle. Full, rich, brine, and tang, then warming citrus. The sweet is apple, salted cookie is evident, light nutty flavors. Salty undertones let you know it's a coastal distillery. It's what Jefferson was trying to achieve with the "at sea" barrels, but didn't. You could tell me it's double the price and I'd believe you. The newer, 40%, sold in a box is much lighter in color and much less flavor. I put them side by side and couldn't believe the color difference. Not worth paying more than $40 for the newer stuff.

Sweet at first, with a bit of spice that comes later. Very little aftertaste, mild overall. Very pleasant. Rich and tasty.

Toffee and poached plums with hints of licorice on the nose. Aniseed notes in a subdued, watery palette with hints of honey and spices and a weak, watery finish.